Monday, June 30, 2014
Today in the Sobel Timeline: June 30
On June 30, 1962, the global supercorporation Kramer Associates detonated the world's first atomic bomb in an isolated part of the north Pacific, the result of a secret four-year research project called the Taichung Project.
Saturday, June 28, 2014
Today in the Sobel Timeline: June 28
On June 28, 1899, Mexican marines from the Pacific Fleet landed at Petropavlovsk, Kamchatka, marking the start of the Siberian campaign of the Great Northern War between Mexico and the Russian Empire.
Friday, June 27, 2014
Today in the Sobel Timeline: June 27
On June 27, 1914, riots broke out in the Mexican port city of Tampico for the second time in two weeks. The French fleet which had been anchored just outside of Mexican territorial waters for five days took this as a signal to begin troop landings. Mexican coast artillery fired on the ships, sinking four and crippling another two, but ten French troop ships made it to the beaches, and over the course of the night, French troops occupied the city, marking the beginning of the Hundred Day War.
Sunday, June 22, 2014
Today in the Sobel Timeline: June 22
On June 22, 1914, the Republic of France and the United States of Mexico drew closer to war when the French fleet entered the Caribbean and anchored off of the Mexican port of Tampico, just beyond the fifteen kilometer limit claimed by the Mexicans. As Sobel remarks, the French seemed to be awaiting further developments.
Thursday, June 19, 2014
Today in the Sobel Timeline: June 19
On June 19, 1851, Mexican President Pedro Hermión gave a speech before Congress defending his prosecution of the Rocky Mountain War, and pledging to continue "until we drive the last North American from our soil, and then we will march upon Burgoyne, and I will personally dictate peace terms to Gilpin and his jackals." However, after finishing his speech, Hermión was shot and killed by a disgruntled former member of the Presidential Guard named Emiliano Zangora. Zangora himself was shot and killed by the Congressional guard while attempting to flee the scene.
Tuesday, June 17, 2014
Today in the Sobel Timeline: June 17
On June 17, 1929, Mexican President Pedro Fuentes announced the creation of the Zwicker Commission, to be chaired by Secretary of the Exchequer Stanley Zwicker. The purpose of the commission was to "investigate large corporations in the United States of Mexico, and make suggestions for legislation." Fuentes was determined to gain control over the Mexican supercorporation Kramer Associates, and he believed that the best way would be to create a government commission to investigate the company, as Governor-General Henderson Dewey had done in the Confederation of North America to gain popular support for his efforts to reform the National Financial Administration.
Sunday, June 15, 2014
Today in the Sobel Timeline: June 15
On June 15, 1820, the Chamber of Representatives of the State of Jefferson accepted Governor Andrew Jackson's proposal for a convention in Mexico City to draft a constitution creating a permanent union of Jefferson and the Republic of Mexico. The Chamber then voted to dissolve itself, to reassemble as a constitutional convention in Mexico City on September 22.
On June 15, 1855, an arbitration panel consisting of representatives from Spain, the Netherlands, and the Germanic Confederation issued a report for a proposed peace treaty ending the Rocky Mountain War between the United States of Mexico and the Confederation of North America.
On June 15, 1855, an arbitration panel consisting of representatives from Spain, the Netherlands, and the Germanic Confederation issued a report for a proposed peace treaty ending the Rocky Mountain War between the United States of Mexico and the Confederation of North America.
Sobel Wiki: An unambitious man
This week's featured article at the Sobel Wiki is on George Vining, the seventh President of the United States of Mexico, and the last to be chosen by Constitutional means for 23 years.
If you were looking for evidence that Robert Sobel was writing For Want of a Nail on the fly, with no larger plan in mind, George Vining would probably be exhibit number one. Sobel introduces Vining in the penultimate paragraph of chapter 16 "The Kinkaid Interlude." President Kinkaid has been assassinated, and the Mexican Senate is deadlocked on the choice of a successor. Vining, "an unambitious man," emerges as a compromise candidate who reluctantly agrees to serve out the remainder of Kinkaid's term of office "for the sake of unity." Sobel goes on to say that the real power in the government would be exercised by Vining's Secretary of State, and that Vining surprised the nation by choosing Thomas Rogers, the leader of the opposition Liberty Party, for the position.
Sobel ends the chapter on that note, then takes up events in Europe in chapter 17 "The Bloody Eighties", and events in the Confederation of North America in chapter 18, "An Age of Renewal." It is only in chapter 19 "The Crisis of Mexican Republicanism" that he returns to Mexico. And it is clear that by then Sobel had changed his mind about what direction he wanted Mexican history to take. George Vining, the reluctant unity candidate, is replaced by a ruthless figure who will turn Mexico into a police state. Thomas Rogers, the power behind the throne, is replaced by a hapless opposition leader who will foolishly acquiesce in the destruction of representative government. And lastly, Sobel introduces us to Benito Hermión, son of former president Pedro Hermión, and the man who will seize control of Mexico and make himself dictator by the end of the chapter.
Sobel didn't even go back and rewrite the end of chapter 16 to make it conform to chapter 19. The result is one of the most severe inconsistencies in the whole book.
If you were looking for evidence that Robert Sobel was writing For Want of a Nail on the fly, with no larger plan in mind, George Vining would probably be exhibit number one. Sobel introduces Vining in the penultimate paragraph of chapter 16 "The Kinkaid Interlude." President Kinkaid has been assassinated, and the Mexican Senate is deadlocked on the choice of a successor. Vining, "an unambitious man," emerges as a compromise candidate who reluctantly agrees to serve out the remainder of Kinkaid's term of office "for the sake of unity." Sobel goes on to say that the real power in the government would be exercised by Vining's Secretary of State, and that Vining surprised the nation by choosing Thomas Rogers, the leader of the opposition Liberty Party, for the position.
Sobel ends the chapter on that note, then takes up events in Europe in chapter 17 "The Bloody Eighties", and events in the Confederation of North America in chapter 18, "An Age of Renewal." It is only in chapter 19 "The Crisis of Mexican Republicanism" that he returns to Mexico. And it is clear that by then Sobel had changed his mind about what direction he wanted Mexican history to take. George Vining, the reluctant unity candidate, is replaced by a ruthless figure who will turn Mexico into a police state. Thomas Rogers, the power behind the throne, is replaced by a hapless opposition leader who will foolishly acquiesce in the destruction of representative government. And lastly, Sobel introduces us to Benito Hermión, son of former president Pedro Hermión, and the man who will seize control of Mexico and make himself dictator by the end of the chapter.
Sobel didn't even go back and rewrite the end of chapter 16 to make it conform to chapter 19. The result is one of the most severe inconsistencies in the whole book.
Saturday, June 14, 2014
Today in the Sobel Timeline: June 14
On June 14, 1902, national elections were held in the United States of Mexico for the first time in 27 years. There were fourteen presidential candidates, none of whom received more than twelve percent of the vote. Kramer Associates President Diego Cortez y Catalán, operating behind the scenes, ordered a runoff election between the three leading candidates.
Thursday, June 12, 2014
Today in the Sobel Timeline: June 12
On June 12, 1778, the Second Continental Congress agreed to an armistice with the British that had been negotiated between recently-chosen president Joseph Galloway and the Earl of Carlisle. The armistice ended the North American Rebellion, bringing the rebellious colonies back under British control.
On June 12, 1884, exiled Mexican Senator Thomas Rogers gave an interview to a reporter from the London Times. Discussing the end of republican government in the United States of Mexico three years earlier, Rogers said, "We did much that was wrong and foolish, but at the time these actions seemed prudent and sensible. Our liberties were taken from us by stealth and over time, and not in a single day. And we helped those who robbed us of our freedom."
Rogers' remarks were reported in the 8 July 1884 issue of the Times.
On June 12, 1914, riots broke out in the French quarter of the Mexican port city of Tampico, provoked by agents of French President Henri Fanchon.
On June 12, 1884, exiled Mexican Senator Thomas Rogers gave an interview to a reporter from the London Times. Discussing the end of republican government in the United States of Mexico three years earlier, Rogers said, "We did much that was wrong and foolish, but at the time these actions seemed prudent and sensible. Our liberties were taken from us by stealth and over time, and not in a single day. And we helped those who robbed us of our freedom."
Rogers' remarks were reported in the 8 July 1884 issue of the Times.
On June 12, 1914, riots broke out in the French quarter of the Mexican port city of Tampico, provoked by agents of French President Henri Fanchon.
Wednesday, June 11, 2014
Today in the Sobel Timeline: June 11
On June 11, 1898, Mexican forces consisting of elements of the California Guard and the Mexican marines pursued fleeing Russian troops across the border into Russian Alaska, marking the first Mexican occupation of Russian territory in the Great Northern War.
Sunday, June 8, 2014
Today in the Sobel Timeline: June 8
On June 8, 1890, the 34th Brigade of Mexican marines under Colonel David Brewster entered the New Granadan capital of Bogotá, an important milestone in the course of the War for Salvation.
Wednesday, June 4, 2014
Today in the Sobel Timeline: June 4
On June 4, 1969, former North American Governor-General Perry Jay was the subject of a vitavised interview by three journalists: Arnold Bittle, Maxwell Jenkins, and Arthur Flick. Among other topics, Jay spoke about his resignation three years earlier, and his advice to his successor, Carter Monaghan. According to Jay, he told Monaghan, "I've left you one problem, and that can be summed up in a single word. It's Mercator."
Monday, June 2, 2014
Today in the Sobel Timeline: June 2
On June 2, 1914, French President Henri Fanchon continued his planned attack on the United States of Mexico by disembarking a regiment of French troops on the Caribbean island colony of Martinique.
Friday, May 30, 2014
Today in the Sobel Timeline: May 30
On May 30, 1898, elements of the Pacific Fleet of the United States of Mexico under Admiral Ephraim Small entered San Francisco harbor and disembarked 20,000 Mexican marines. The marines marched north to join the California Guard, which was holding off an invading Russian regiment in the Great Northern War.
Thursday, May 29, 2014
Today in the Sobel Timeline: May 29
On May 29, 1933, negotiations began in London for a military alliance between Great Britain and the Confederation of North America, the centerpiece of Governor-General Douglas Watson's new foreign policy initiative. Although Sobel never says so, the alliance was presumably either defeated in the Grand Council, or was cancelled by Watson's successor, Bruce Hogg.
Wednesday, May 28, 2014
Today in the Sobel Timeline: May 28
On May 28, 1899, a naval force of the United States of Mexico began occupying the Aleutian Islands, completing the conquest of Russian Alaska that began the preceding spring following the outbreak of the Great Northern War.
Tuesday, May 27, 2014
Today in the Sobel Timeline: May 27
On May 27, 1778, the Second Continental Congress agreed to ask Lord North for an armistice based on a proposal presented by the Earl of Carlisle, in which most of the rebels would be granted amnesty, and the North Ministry would propose a plan of limited self-government for the colonies based on Joseph Galloway's Plan of Proposed Union. The Earl accepted the request, and sent word to Generals Howe, Clinton, and Burgoyne of the agreed truce.
Monday, May 26, 2014
Rebecca Watson: An experiment in clickbait
PZ Myers of Phyrangula once observed that invoking the dread name of atheist feminist Rebecca Watson provokes idiots into raging fury. I intend to test that assertion.
Among many other noteworthy accomplishments, Watson has inspired Watson's Law: "Anytime you speak up about harassment, harassment gets worse." The latest example of Watson's Law in action is that the creator of the hashtag #yesallwomen has had to make her account private, and has asked that she not be connected with it by name, because she has gotten such a high level of threats and harassment since starting it.
Rebecca Watson said it, and once again the wretched hive of scum and misogyny that is the internet has proven her right.
Now, a typical post here at the Johnny Pez blog gets maybe 20 views and zero responses. Will invoking the Dread Name attract any idiots my way? We shall see.
UPDATE: June 4, 2014. Nine days later, the above post has received 22 views and zero responses. Sadly, not even the Dread Name is enough to attract notice to this blog.
Among many other noteworthy accomplishments, Watson has inspired Watson's Law: "Anytime you speak up about harassment, harassment gets worse." The latest example of Watson's Law in action is that the creator of the hashtag #yesallwomen has had to make her account private, and has asked that she not be connected with it by name, because she has gotten such a high level of threats and harassment since starting it.
Rebecca Watson said it, and once again the wretched hive of scum and misogyny that is the internet has proven her right.
Now, a typical post here at the Johnny Pez blog gets maybe 20 views and zero responses. Will invoking the Dread Name attract any idiots my way? We shall see.
UPDATE: June 4, 2014. Nine days later, the above post has received 22 views and zero responses. Sadly, not even the Dread Name is enough to attract notice to this blog.
Sobel Wiki: Scepter'd Isle
This week's featured article at the Sobel Wiki is on Great Britain.
Sobel's focus on the Confederation of North America and the United States of Mexico means that Great Britain becomes steadily less important to the story as the narrative moves away from the point of divergence in 1777 and the C.N.A. gains steadily more autonomy through the 19th century. Among other things, this means that we have no idea whether Ireland was united with Great Britain as it was in our history in 1800. Given that the American and French Revolutions were unsuccessful, and given the example of the C.N.A. as a British possession with an autonomous government, it is possible that Ireland would have retained its own Parliament into the 20th century.
Another issue Sobel glosses over are diplomatic relations between Great Britain and the C.N.A. Given that the C.N.A. is basically a larger version of our own history's Canada, it's useful to use Anglo-Canadian relations as a basis for comparison. Our own history's analogue to the drafting of the Second Britannic Design was the Confederation of 1867. Following Confederation, Canada's first Prime Minister, John A. Macdonald, sent an unofficial envoy to represent Canada in London. In 1880, the office of Canadian envoy to Britain was formalized under the name High Commissioner, and this set a precedent for diplomatic envoys between Commonwealth nations.
Sobel makes no mention of a formal North American envoy to London after passage of the Second Britannic Design in 1842. However, he does mention that Governor-General William Johnson sent his Minister of State, Montgomery Harcourt, to London in 1853 to seek increased British investment in the C.N.A., which suggests that there was not a regular North American diplomatic mission in London at the time, though the C.N.A. did have its own Office of State, and presumably maintained diplomatic relations with other nations, especially the U.S.M. By contrast, Canada did not have an equivalent government department until 1909, and since the Canadians wanted to avoid calling it the Foreign Ministry (since Canadian foreign policy was still controlled by the British government), it was called the Department of External Affairs, and Canada didn't begin establishing formal diplomatic relations with other countries until the 1920s.
By the time the Global War broke out in 1939, Great Britain had a regular diplomatic mission to the C.N.A. headed by an ambassador (and vice versa, presumably). Given Ezra Gallivan's isolationist foreign policy, including his desire to distance the C.N.A. from Great Britain, it is likely that this dated from his administration in 1888 at the latest.
At the end of For Want of a Nail, Sobel speculated that in the future, the C.N.A. might form a union with the United British Empire, or even that Great Britain might join the C.N.A. as a new confederation.
Sobel's focus on the Confederation of North America and the United States of Mexico means that Great Britain becomes steadily less important to the story as the narrative moves away from the point of divergence in 1777 and the C.N.A. gains steadily more autonomy through the 19th century. Among other things, this means that we have no idea whether Ireland was united with Great Britain as it was in our history in 1800. Given that the American and French Revolutions were unsuccessful, and given the example of the C.N.A. as a British possession with an autonomous government, it is possible that Ireland would have retained its own Parliament into the 20th century.
Another issue Sobel glosses over are diplomatic relations between Great Britain and the C.N.A. Given that the C.N.A. is basically a larger version of our own history's Canada, it's useful to use Anglo-Canadian relations as a basis for comparison. Our own history's analogue to the drafting of the Second Britannic Design was the Confederation of 1867. Following Confederation, Canada's first Prime Minister, John A. Macdonald, sent an unofficial envoy to represent Canada in London. In 1880, the office of Canadian envoy to Britain was formalized under the name High Commissioner, and this set a precedent for diplomatic envoys between Commonwealth nations.
Sobel makes no mention of a formal North American envoy to London after passage of the Second Britannic Design in 1842. However, he does mention that Governor-General William Johnson sent his Minister of State, Montgomery Harcourt, to London in 1853 to seek increased British investment in the C.N.A., which suggests that there was not a regular North American diplomatic mission in London at the time, though the C.N.A. did have its own Office of State, and presumably maintained diplomatic relations with other nations, especially the U.S.M. By contrast, Canada did not have an equivalent government department until 1909, and since the Canadians wanted to avoid calling it the Foreign Ministry (since Canadian foreign policy was still controlled by the British government), it was called the Department of External Affairs, and Canada didn't begin establishing formal diplomatic relations with other countries until the 1920s.
By the time the Global War broke out in 1939, Great Britain had a regular diplomatic mission to the C.N.A. headed by an ambassador (and vice versa, presumably). Given Ezra Gallivan's isolationist foreign policy, including his desire to distance the C.N.A. from Great Britain, it is likely that this dated from his administration in 1888 at the latest.
At the end of For Want of a Nail, Sobel speculated that in the future, the C.N.A. might form a union with the United British Empire, or even that Great Britain might join the C.N.A. as a new confederation.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)